green live naturali logo iconLive
Naturali
Subscribe

Fermented Foods for Gut Health: Worth the Hype?

Are fermented foods worth the hype? What they do in your gut, which ones still have live microbes, which are best tested, and how much to eat each day.

Are fermented foods worth all the hype?

It's hard to say. Most of that hype comes from the microbes that make them.

As we learn more about the microbiome's role in gut health, it's natural to turn to food that's full of bacteria and ask if it can help "feed" or "restore" yours.

It's fun to speculate, but what does the current research have to say about fermented foods and the role they play in gut health?

What counts as a fermented food?

An expert panel defines a fermented food as "foods made through desired microbial growth and enzymatic conversions of food components". Basically, it means food that's been intentionally made by microbes (bacteria, yeasts, or molds). The microbes' enzymes break down parts of the food, like the sugars in milk or cabbage, and turn them into new things like lactic acid.

What separates fermented food from food that's just gone bad is that the process is carried out intentionally.

Foods that contain fermented ingredients aren't fermented foods themselves. For example, vegetables pickled in vinegar aren't fermented foods, even though vinegar is fermented.

But just because a food is fermented doesn't mean it still contains live microbes when you eat it. It just means that it contained them at some point while it was made. Baking, pasteurizing, and heat-treating foods will kill these microbes. Bread, soy sauce, roasted coffee, and wine are all fermented foods but don't contain any live microbes.

Fermented foods that skip the heating step usually still have live microbes, like:

  • Yogurt
  • Sour cream
  • Kefir
  • Most cheeses
  • Miso
  • Non-heated fermented vegetables (refrigerated sauerkraut, kimchi)
  • Non-heated salami, pepperoni, fermented sausages
  • Most kombuchas

To spot a fermented food that still has live cultures in it, look for:

  • The refrigerated section. A jar on a room-temp shelf usually isn't live.
  • "Live and active cultures" or "contains live cultures" on the label.
  • "Unpasteurized" on fermented vegetables.

The label "made by fermentation" on its own doesn't tell you that the microbes are still alive.

Is a fermented food a probiotic?

So if a fermented food contains live bacterial cultures, does that mean it's a probiotic?

Not necessarily. A probiotic is a defined live microbe that's been studied in research and has a shown benefit at a specific dose. A food can only earn the title of "probiotic" when the exact microbes that are in the food are known and have actually been shown to provide a health benefit.

Fermented foods are different. One can hold many different strains of bacteria, most of which aren't well defined in the research. And its mix of bacteria can change over time.

That doesn't mean that fermented foods are worse than probiotics. It just means they're different.

It also means you eat fermented foods for the same reason you eat other food: for what's in them. Here, that's what fermentation did to the food and the mix of microbes it carries. You don't eat them to get a specific bacterial strain and its benefits, since you don't even know which strains you're getting. And even if you do, those strains might not have clearly defined researched benefits. If you're trying to help a specific condition, knowing the studied strain still matters.

What do fermented foods do for your gut?

There are a few potential ways that fermented foods could help with gut health. First, the food itself changes chemically in ways that could be beneficial for your gut. Second, it can carry new compounds. And third, it can bring microbes that pass through your gut.

When microbes ferment food, they're essentially digesting part of it before you eat it. In dairy products, they eat some of the lactose, the milk sugar that causes digestive problems in people with lactose intolerance. Less lactose means less of it left over for your gut bacteria to turn into gas. That's why many people who have trouble with milk do fine with yogurt and kefir. Microbes can also partly pre-digest proteins, fats, and starches. And they break down anti-nutrients, like phytic acid in grains, which can keep your body from absorbing minerals like iron and zinc.

Fermentation can also add things to the food that the raw food didn't have, like new vitamins and some organic acids.

Fermented foods can also bring their own bacteria into your gut. These microbes can survive the trip to your colon, but they don't stick around for long. While they're passing through, they make up only about 0.1-1% of the bacteria in your colon. So any effect probably depends on eating them regularly.

It's inaccurate to say that eating fermented foods helps "repopulate" or "restore" your gut microbiome. Instead, the bacteria in fermented foods interact with the bacteria that are already in your gut. On the way through, they can make compounds like lactic acid, crowd out harmful bacteria, and send signals that regulate your gut lining and immune cells.

In one small Stanford trial, healthy adults worked up to about six servings of fermented foods a day. Their microbiome diversity rose (a wider range of bacteria in their gut), and several markers of inflammation fell. They started at less than one serving a day and ramped up over four weeks, eating foods like yogurt, kefir, kombucha, kimchi, and vegetable brine drinks.

The trial was small, so the results are promising, not proven.

When researchers pooled several trials of fermented foods in healthy adults, they found a modest benefit for bowel movement regularity. But they rated their certainty in these results as low to moderate.

Learn 5-minute habits every week

Targeted to your symptoms, backed by evidence.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Which fermented foods are best for gut health?

It's hard to say which fermented foods are best, mostly because a lot of them don't have enough research behind them for us to be able to point to a proven, consistent health benefit.

Fermented dairy has the most trials, specifically yogurt and fermented milk. In studies that followed people over time, eating yogurt is associated with lower body mass index (BMI), smaller waist circumference, and a lower risk of type 2 diabetes and heart disease. Fermented milk is associated with better blood sugar control.

The next food up is kefir. Out of fermented foods, it's the most studied single food, but most of its trials are low quality. One trial found that kefir helped antibiotics clear H. pylori more often than antibiotics without kefir.

Kefir is also well tolerated by many people with lactose intolerance. In one small trial of 15 people, it caused less gas than milk. A few early studies suggest it may help with constipation, but more research is needed.

In one small trial of sauerkraut, eating 75g a day for 6 weeks lowered symptom scores in people with IBS.

Other fermented foods like kimchi, kombucha, miso, and tempeh are barely tested in human trials, despite having some of the most hype surrounding them. As of a 2019 review, none of them had a single randomized trial on gut health, and kombucha had no human gut studies at all. Before we can say for a fact that these foods carry health benefits, more research is needed.

None of this, however, means that fermented foods aren't worth trying. Just because research hasn't been performed to discover their benefits doesn't mean that they don't exist. It just means we don't really know what they can do. And no trials have compared fermented foods head to head, so the best one is the one you'll actually eat. So if you try one and find that your gut does well on it, keep it.

How much fermented food per day?

There's no set amount of fermented food to shoot for each day, like the daily goals we have for protein or fiber. Most dietary guidelines don't include live microbes at all. To establish a guideline, we'd need trials that test different amounts against each other.

What we do know is what studies used. Some tested one serving (100g of sauerkraut a day), while others used up to six. Most of the pooled trials tested dairy drinks with far more microbes than a typical jar of sauerkraut. So far, more hasn't clearly been better.

People who eat more foods with live microbes tend to have slightly better health markers, although that data also counts raw fruit and vegetables.

A sensible way to start is to add one serving of a live-culture food a day, and build up over a few weeks. Since there's no standard dose, it's mostly up to you and what you feel helps your situation.

Who should go slow?

For most healthy people, fermented foods are well tolerated. A few groups should start slowly.

Anyone who commonly experiences bloating should start slow, since some people bloat when they first add fermented foods.

People with histamine sensitivities should take care. Fermentation makes histamine and other similar compounds, so these foods can trigger headaches or migraines in some people.

Anyone limiting salt or alcohol should go easy on fermented foods. Some are salty and some contain a little alcohol, so moderation is best.

If you have IBS and are trying to see if fermented foods will help you, the best thing to do is monitor how you respond. Make sure to track your symptoms as you introduce the fermented foods, and what happens after you eat them. Take note of any improvements or changes when you increase the amount you eat as well.

In Summary

If you're interested in introducing fermented foods into your diet but don't know where to start, pick one live-culture food you'll actually eat. Start with one serving a day, and build from there slowly.

Don't expect it to be a magical cure for your gut. Instead, understand that it's a nutritious food like any other that can help add diversity to your diet. So far, the benefits for your gut look modest and early, like slightly more regular bowel movements.

Ultimately, fermented foods can be one promising piece of the puzzle. The only way to find out if they help you is to try one, track how your gut responds, and keep eating it if you notice a positive difference.

Live Naturali may earn a commission from links to products we recommend, at no extra cost to you.

Stop guessing what to do about the symptoms your doctor can't explain.

Every week, we'll send you current research translated into natural habits that target your symptoms.

Dozens of studies condensed into a 5-minute read. Act on evidence, not blind trust.

✓ Every claim cited · 100% free · Unsubscribe anytime